The End of an Era: Broadway Farewells Tony-Nominated Dead Outlaw

As the month of June draws to a close, Broadway is saying farewell to a beloved and Tony-nominated musical that has captivated audiences for several months. Dead Outlaw, a unique and daring production that follows the life (or rather the afterlife) of 19th-century American outlaw Elmer McCurdy, will wrap up its run on June 29. The show, which debuted on Broadway on April 27, 2025, received significant praise from critics and audiences alike. It earned several distinguished accolades, including Tony Award nominations for Best Musical, Best Actor, Best Direction, and Best Musical Score. Despite its warm reviews and various critical achievements, Dead Outlaw struggled to gain a place among New York's theatergoers, resulting in lower-than-average ticket sales throughout its time on Broadway. In a statement acknowledging the show's final performance, producers Lia Vollack and Sonia Friedman spoke about the show's time in New York and their satisfaction with the production. "Like Elmer McCurdy, Dead Outlaw is a true outlier—strange, singular, and enduring. It never followed the rules—and that has made it one of the most daring and fulfilling productions we’ve had the privilege to stage," the producers said. Despite glowing reviews and a loyal following, the commercial momentum just wasn’t fast enough in a crowded season. As the show reminds us, sometimes the most incredible lives are cut short. This may be the end of Dead Outlaw’s time on Broadway, but we believe deeply in its future and the afterlife it so richly deserves. Endless thanks to the creators, cast, crew, co-producers, investors, and Audible for bringing it to life. It’s been an honor.” The closing of Dead Outlaw marks the end of an era on Broadway, but it also serves as a reminder of the importance of daring and unique productions that challenge the status quo. The show may be gone from the Great White Way, but its legacy will live on in the hearts of those who have experienced its thrilling and unforgettable performances.